Log in

No account? Create an account
17 October 2010 @ 07:52 am
Does My Icon Look Fat In This: Part II  

+ It's been a year since the first successful Does My Icon Look Fat In This? Icon Concrit Meme took place, so we at just_delicious decided it was time for Part II.
+ Ever wondered how people really look at your icons? Think of this meme as crunch time for your icons - in a good way.
+ Simply comment with your username, where you post you icons, and up to TEN example icons [should you wish to include them].
+ People will reply anonymously with what they really think of your icons.
+ WANK FTL. If you're going to be critical of someones icons, please don't be an A$$ about it. Find a way to be constructive without being obscenely rude - if you love something a maker as done, show them through examples (remember though: HOTLINKING IS EVIL) - but also comment on what you think they could improve upon.

Does my icon look fat in this? || MY THREAD

Lilith: Break - This is deliciouscelestial_m00n on February 19th, 2011 08:18 pm (UTC)
celestial_m00n at clockwisedoom 

I'm started to color manga in April 2010. Any critiques are welcome xD
nna_chan: Are You Alice || That's ridiculousnna_chan on February 20th, 2011 02:13 am (UTC)
APRIL 2010 ?!! SERIOUSLY ??...

but anyway Lilichi..
your strong point is cropping and colouring! vibrant and rich colours~ and the cropping makes it is an outstanding icon..
to sometimes the texture is making it less beautiful (like in that Sebby icon)...
but overall you have a great icon! and text composition!
Lilith: Jack - Delightedcelestial_m00n on February 20th, 2011 03:12 am (UTC)
YES SERIOUSLY. Actually I colored some pages before that by mouse, but I'm not usually do that until I have a tablet.♥

Hmm just because I love colorful things so much! (I'm still like a kid orz) Yeah someone's said that to me before xD I'll try not to use textures like that again, hehehe ♥

Thanks so much Nna, you're the best! ♥
Cyan: Ouran Hosts Rainbowcool_spectrum on February 20th, 2011 05:31 am (UTC)
I am a huge fan of your icons XD I love your coloring, I love the colors, I love your cropping. My only crit is that you don't make icons for any of my fandoms DX
(Anonymous) on February 20th, 2011 01:17 pm (UTC)
Really like your skin's coloring <3 and your choice in colors really suit the style of PH's art :D I still love your icons, but somehow I prefer more your previous icons ( to November ), I can't exactly say what is a difference, but probably a background and 'shining'? Hope that you know what I mean, but it's probably only fault my weird taste, so don't worry :)
Lilith: Break - This is deliciouscelestial_m00n on February 20th, 2011 02:27 pm (UTC)
Thanks so much for the compliment! And don't worry, your taste is not weird at all! I'll think more about it~ I got a bit too lazy to deal with the background, haha but I'll try next time! Thank you ♥
feé: ccryfee on February 21st, 2011 02:07 am (UTC)
Ohh, here you are. XD

Your manga coloring is pretty and neat; my only suggestion is that your icons look blurry sometimes -- try more contrast and a bit of sharpening? Also, it seems like you keep using/recycling the same color scheme for your manga coloring/icons... try experimenting more?
I like your manga coloring style though, very PH-ish. :p
Lilith: Oz - ^^celestial_m00n on February 21st, 2011 03:01 am (UTC)
Waaaaa thanks so much Fee!! I'm glad I have a wonderful friend like you!

Yeah! Actually I did think about sharpening them, but when I finish an icon, I always forget to sharpen it orz
Hmm... That because I think it'll make my style only! But you're right, I should try experimenting more.

Thanks so much Fee ♥♥♥ /hugs tightttttt
yunhoxarayunhoxara on March 26th, 2011 09:11 pm (UTC)
I don't see manga icons much but these just attract my attention. I love the cleanness and vibrant colors, less is more and you'd done these to perfection! :P